I haven't seen any references to the new Mongolia daylight saving, are there any on the web? It seems that there are also no references in your mail. Since so many sources differ about Mongolia, I would advice a careful approach to these changes, to avoid having to do them over and over again (well, I admit that this how we always manage time zone changes from Israel, but here there is no indication that the Mongol government is changing it's mind all the time, as they do in Tel Aviv). Actually I checked out mongolian time zones just a few weeks ago, but could not find other sources than <http://www.mongoliatourism.gov.mn/general.htm> which I believe we received from Oscar van Vlijmen in Holland. It is true that it doesn't work anymore, but that is simply because the page general.htm is not available anymore. If you use http://www.mongoliatourism.gov.mn/toc.htm , you will get into a general page, which further down has a paragraph "Time Differences" It seems that these pages were recently changed concerning visa rules, but I don't know if the timezone information is up-to-date. They report two time zones, the eastern consisting of provinces Khovd, Bayan Ulgii and Uvs, on GMT+7, and the rest on GMT+8. They specifically claim that Mongolia no longer "puts forward its clocks by 1 hour in the summer months". I would doubt a lot that the Choibalsan zone on GMT+9 has existed since 1983 as Shanks claims, but we lack authoritative information, since all the authorities seem to disagree. However, the above page I still consider as the only authoritative web page I have seen yet, e.g. published by the mongolian government. I found a map of Mongolia from these pages which showed each province with borders to the other provinces, also population counters, however I did not write the URLs down, and I couldn't find them again today. I am pretty sure that the provinces Govi-Altai and Zavkhan were to the east of the Khovd, Bayan Ulgii and Uvs provinces on these maps (not to the west).
(Maybe they redrew the provincial lines lately? It's such a pain to deal with a nation that is still nearly half nomadic. :-)
I can only agree more! We will have to wait for the nomadic computers ... :-) E.g. those that are powered by Sun light or maybe saddle pressure power :-) Regards, ---------- From: Paul Eggert[SMTP:eggert@twinsun.com] Sent: Domingo 13 de Mayo de 2001 0:52 To: rmcdow@enteles.com Cc: tz@elsie.nci.nih.gov Subject: Re: Mongolia time zones
Date: Sun, 13 May 2001 10:59:24 -0800 From: Rives McDow <rmcdow@enteles.com>
In addition to Mongolia starting daylight savings as reported earlier (adopted dst on April 27, 2001,0200 local time, ending Sept. 28, 2001),
Thanks. Sorry, I missed that somehow. Is this a one-time deal, or are they permanently instituting DST, presumably using a last-Friday-of-April-and-September rule?
there are three time zones.
I guess it's time to add a new Asia/Choibalsan Zone. Shanks wrote that they diverged from Ulaanbaatar time in April 1983, so I'll assume that. Also, your "0200 local time" agrees with Shanks from mid-1984 on, but disagrees with the IATA; I'll assume that the IATA has been wrong (which wouldn't be the first time).
Provinces 19 hours from the IDL: Bayan-ulgii, Uvs, Khovd, Zavkhan, Govi-Altai
<http://www.mongoliatourism.gov.mn/general.htm> (now inaccessible, alas) reported in 1999-09 that only Bayan-ulgii, Uvs, and Khovd were in that time zone. Did the other two provinces switch zones? They are further west than Khovd, so for now, I'll assume that the earlier reference missed those two provinces. (That reference claimed that there was no third time zone in the east, which disagreed with Shanks and other sources, so it was on my "questionable" list anyway.)
Provinces 20 hours from the IDL: Khovsgol, Bulgan, Arkhangai, Khentii, Tov, Bayankhongor, Ovorkhangai, Dundgovi, Dornogovi, Omnogovi,
Provinces 21 hours from the IDL: Choibalsan, Sukhbaatar
Just as a point of trivia, <http://www.world-gazetteer.com/c/c_mn.htm> says that Choibalsan is in the province of Dornod. Your list also omits the province of Selenge, which is listed in that source and at the CIA. (Maybe they redrew the provincial lines lately? It's such a pain to deal with a nation that is still nearly half nomadic. :-)