
From: "Jamie" <jamie@maxnet-usa.net> Date: Sun, 11 Jun 2000 22:09:23 -0400 Doris Chase Doane has a book out on Time Changes through out the world. I just downloaded your timezone information from the ftp.btx.com site and noticed that it doesn't seem like you really have very much information. The tz database concentrates on time changes since 1970, for two reasons. First, the tz code is based on the POSIX.1 computer standard, and portable POSIX.1 time stamps cannot occur before 1970. Second, it makes the database a lot smaller if we partition the world only into locations whose time histories differ since 1970, and ignore any extra partitioning due to earlier differences. It'd be nice if someone extended the tz database backward in time to all known time stamp histories, but that would be a lot of work and nobody has done it (yet). I'm trying to create an atlas that provides the correct time zone based upon not just the date but the town and place. If you find errors in the tz database, please send email to <tz@elsie.nci.nih.gov>. For more complete coverage of dates before 1970, I recommend Shanks's time zone history atlases. They do not always agree with Doane, but they seem to be popular among astrologers these days. Please see: http://www.astro.com/atlas/index.html http://astrocom.com/software/ACS_PC_Atlas.htm http://astrocom.com/books/xrefa.htm#SHANKS there are frequently situations where the uncertainty about the time was actually the norm rather than the rule. You're quite right. For example, what was the time zone of Wise, Virginia on October 18, 1927? According to <http://www.astrodatabank.com/NMScottGeorgeC.htm>, Doane and Shanks disagree and in this case Doane's probably correct. Or, to take a modern example, what is the time zone of Pangnirntung, Nunavut, Canada? The province disagrees with the city, so city and commercial offices operate in one time zone and provincial offices operate on another. (How will your database address problems like Pangnirtung's?)

Paul, Doane and Shanks
disagree and in this case Doane's probably correct. Or, to take a modern example, what is the time zone of Pangnirntung, Nunavut, Canada? The province disagrees with the city, so city and commercial offices operate in one time zone and provincial offices operate on another. (How will your database address problems like Pangnirtung's?)
With as much diplomacy as possible. hmmm, Thanks so much for your prompt reply. It is a pleasure to receive knowledgable mail. I'm familiar with Zip's son's work as well as the work of Lois and Astrodienst. I have a copy of the ACS atlas on my machine. I guess I should know more about Shanks, but since Pottenger is the better known of the two, I wasn't aware that it was his work that Pottenger was programming. The atlas actually seems to be the most problematic portion of programming astrological dates and I can see the wisdom of Pottenger getting into it at an early point in time. Still, this is a hobby for me and I'm looking to earn money at it (yet). For now, just seeking my mark. Thanks again Paul, Jamie
participants (2)
-
Jamie
-
Paul Eggert