Hi, I would like to propose that Asia/Nicosia move to Europe/Nicosia. The Asia file makes this statement: # Classically, Cyprus belongs to Asia; e.g. see Herodotus, Histories, I.72. # However, for various reasons many users expect to find it under Europe. While I appreciate the nod to classical antiquity, its classification under Asia is wholly irrelevant today. This statement appears to trivialize the "various reasons" why "many users" tend to expect it under Europe. . Cyprus is a European country . The culture is decidedly Europe-facing . It is a member state of the European Union . Its currency is the Euro . It has participated in the Eurovision Song Contest since 1981 . Its time zone is Eastern European Time (EET) . The predominant culture and language is Greek . The earliest historical reference to Cyprus in the 15th century BC was in Mycenaean Greek . The Asia file itself even mentions this: "# IATA SSIM (1998-09) has Cyprus using EU rules for the first time." There is nothing Asian about Cyprus today. Nobody in the country attempting to set the local time zone is going to look for it under Asia. If we don't find it under Europe, we assume it was erroneously omitted. Steven
Hi Steven, - There are many European cultures out of Europe, like Canadians and Russians. - There are many territories under the sovereignty of an EU member state. - There are many UTC+02:00 countries in Africa and Asia. - The predominant culture and language is English and Spanish in America. - It is Greek colony in Asia. - Turkey is in both Europe and Asia. - Kazakhstan is in both Europe and Asia. - Russia is in both Europe and Asia. - Azerbaijan is in both Europe and Asia. - Georgia is in both Europe and Asia. - Cyprus is a Greek colony in Asia. - Cyprus is in Asia. - People should learn geography, not assume politics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_transcontinental_countries On Fri, Oct 2, 2015 at 8:42 PM, Steven Nicolaou <steven.nicolaou@gmail.com> wrote:
Hi,
I would like to propose that Asia/Nicosia move to Europe/Nicosia.
The Asia file makes this statement:
# Classically, Cyprus belongs to Asia; e.g. see Herodotus, Histories, I.72.
# However, for various reasons many users expect to find it under Europe.
While I appreciate the nod to classical antiquity, its classification under Asia is wholly irrelevant today. This statement appears to trivialize the “various reasons” why “many users” tend to expect it under Europe.
· Cyprus is a European country
· The culture is decidedly Europe-facing
· It is a member state of the European Union
· Its currency is the Euro
· It has participated in the Eurovision Song Contest since 1981
· Its time zone is Eastern European Time (EET)
· The predominant culture and language is Greek
· The earliest historical reference to Cyprus in the 15th century BC was in Mycenaean Greek
· The Asia file itself even mentions this: “# IATA SSIM (1998-09) has Cyprus using EU rules for the first time.”
There is nothing Asian about Cyprus today. Nobody in the country attempting to set the local time zone is going to look for it under Asia. If we don’t find it under Europe, we assume it was erroneously omitted.
Steven
Steven Nicolaou wrote:
I would like to propose that Asia/Nicosia move to Europe/Nicosia.
It is already available under both names, so there's no technical need to move. As the Theory file says, ordinary users should not need to worry whether the data are named 'Asia/Nicosia' or 'Europe/Nicosia' internally, and instead can use localized names such as 'Λευκωσία', 'Lefkoşa', and 'Նիկոսիա'. A common set of localized names is maintained by the CLDR project <http://cldr.unicode.org/> and if these are incorrect for your locale I suggest writing to the CLDR maintainers.
participants (3)
-
Ilhan Yumer -
Paul Eggert -
Steven Nicolaou