Continents in tz database? (was: Cyprus)
What is the practical necessity to support continent information with the tz database entries ? Are there any ambiguities otherwise, or is it just a historical convention ? Is it continent information at all ? Besides the continents you find also tags like Pacific and Atlantic in it, so I assume the main reason is to have some impression where this zone is. Inspecting the tz files it seems to me that this information is not necessarily needed, because the entries can be distinguished by the city name unambiguously. If that would not be the case I'd add the country. My understanding is that timezones are bound to countries and their legislation, while continents are mainly geologically defined. Removing continent information would remove the somewhat political question with Cyprus. If continent information is considered necessary in the tz database, then, from a practical point of view, I assume Cyprus would better fit in the European/EU sector - occasionally the same for Turkey in the future -, because of the orientation towards the EU. With the political, religious, social and cultural background of Cyprus, it would never come to my mind to search for Cyprus in Asia, Africa, or elsewhere. But that's just me :-) Janis --- Janis Papanagnou Janis.P@beer.com
<<On Fri, 15 Sep 2000 16:31:13 +0200, Janis.Papanagnou@varetis.de said:
What is the practical necessity to support continent information with the tz database entries ?
For user-interface purposes, it makes life much easier to have users select from a list of regions first, rather than offering a list of two-hundred-odd countries right off the bat. (Users still complain about having to page down to the very end of ``Americas'' to find ``United States'' -- since that's where at least 50% of the users are.) -GAWollman
Quick answer.Get United States to change its name so that it will be at the top of an alphabetic sort (English language)
-----Original Message----- From: Garrett Wollman [mailto:wollman@khavrinen.lcs.mit.edu] Sent: September 15, 2000 12:08 PM To: Janis.Papanagnou@varetis.de Cc: tz@elsie.nci.nih.gov Subject: Continents in tz database? (was: Cyprus)
<<On Fri, 15 Sep 2000 16:31:13 +0200, Janis.Papanagnou@varetis.de said:
What is the practical necessity to support continent information with the tz database entries ?
For user-interface purposes, it makes life much easier to have users select from a list of regions first, rather than offering a list of two-hundred-odd countries right off the bat. (Users still complain about having to page down to the very end of ``Americas'' to find ``United States'' -- since that's where at least 50% of the users are.)
-GAWollman
participants (3)
-
Garrett Wollman -
Infoman Inc. -
Janis.Papanagnou@varetis.de